Dutton-Goldfield Acclaim at JamesSuckling.com (video)
We’re incredibly honored and grateful to receive such outstanding reviews from Jim Gordon, Executive Editor at JamesSuckling.com, one of the most respected voices in the world of wine. Jim’s thoughtful tasting notes and high scores mean the world to our team, especially as we continue our commitment to crafting wines that express the beauty and character of our coastal vineyards. Thank you, Jim, for recognizing our work—we invite you to hear more from him directly in this video below sharing his impressions of our 2021 Devil’s Gulch Vineyard Pinot Noir.
The reviews were published as part of their Monthly Report in March 2025 (paywall):
94 pts - Dutton-Goldfield Pinot Noir Sonoma County Green Valley of Russian River Valley Dutton Ranch Emerald Ridge Vineyard 2022
So well balanced, well integrated and flavorful. It's complex and delicious, from the vivid aroma of sweet cherries to the tangy, fresh texture that supports red and sour cherry, cranberry, cinnamon bark, pine needle and mushroom flavors. Great acidity gives it a linear, focused expression that drives through to a lingering finish. Drink or hold.
94 pts - Dutton-Goldfield Chardonnay Sonoma County Green Valley of Russian River Valley Dutton Ranch Walker Hill Vineyard 2022
So elegant, silky, delicious, nicely rich and layered. Medium-bodied. Made from grapevines planted in the 1980s using the Wente clone and barrel fermented with indigenous yeast. It's nicely balanced and fresh despite all the richness. Creamy lemon curd, marzipan and poached pears. Drink now or hold.
93 pts - Dutton-Goldfield Pinot Noir Sonoma County Green Valley of Russian River Valley Fox Den Vineyard 2022
A broad, rather rich and plummy wine with a gorgeous, relaxed fruit character and a smooth texture. Dark cherries, black plums, dark chocolate and dried blueberries fill the palate. Full-bodied with light tannins and a good sense of richness. Drink now or hold.
92 pts - Dutton-Goldfield Chardonnay Sonoma County Russian River Valley Dutton Ranch 2022
Good, bright acidity adds nice balance to this harmonious, buttery-tasting wine from a longtime outstanding winemaker. Golden apple, vanilla bean and tangy citrus flavors make an appetizing blend, while a full body gives a satisfying mouthfeel. Drink now.
92 pts - Dutton-Goldfield Pinot Noir Sonoma County Russian River Valley Dutton Ranch 2022
A vivid, cherry-scented wine that's nicely complex and has the needed structure for a vivid mouthfeel. Red cherry, sour cherry, rhubarb and black tea flavors show pure pinot character on a medium body braced by moderate tannins. Drink now.
